Today: Oct 30, 2025

– and there was no one left to speak for me.

3 mins read
6 years ago
Change font size:

By Sidonja Manushi

 

Martin Niemà¶ller emerged as an outspoken public foe of Adolf Hitler and spent the last seven years of Nazi rule in concentration camps.

He is perhaps best remembered for his postwar words, which go as follows:

“First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out – because I

was not a socialist.

Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out –

because I was not a trade unionist.

Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out – because I

was not a Jew.

Then they came for me – and there was no one left to speak for me.”

 A few days after Socialist Prime Minister Edi Rama carried on with his controversial local elections, marked by an extremely low voter turnout, a resigned opposition, no real competition for the Socialist representatives in most districts and irregularities conducted in broad daylight for the world to see, reading Niemà¶ller’s words gives me goosebumps like never before. This morning, one of Rama’s adherents (their ministerial posts don’t seem to matter much, anymore) came out and announced an updated draft law aiming to decapitate press freedom based on the lawlessness of defamation and the “respect” towards human rights. Rama’s “anti-defamation” package, ironically coming some weeks after he himself promised to stop calling journalists doing their job “trash bins,” seeks to formalize and regulate all online media through enforced registration. Each media outlet will then be bound to ensure that all articles are true, non-defamatory, and objective and must not be used for criminal purposes. Albania is one of the few countries in Europe where libel and defamation are still considered as criminal, as well as civil offences.

Albania wants to be like France, but Albania’s Prime Minister cannot handle a country where journalists are allowed to think, say, write and, if necessary, even mock their political figures, alla Charlie Hebdo style.  

Albania wants to be like Germany, but Albania’s Prime Minister cannot grant journalists the right to investigate and report freely, because that violates his human rights, and the PM’s human rights are more important than the human rights of those who journalists protect.  

Albania wants to be like the US, but Albania’s Prime Minister does not, cannot, fathom stepping down when caught in fault or, even worse, when his own people stop trusting him.

And yet, what is more concerning is everyone’s apathy towards this fast-growing plague.  They came for the workers and the taxpayers, the political opponents and the journalists,  the students and the thinkers, the doers and the believers.

On its way to forty years in the past, there will be no one left to speak for Albania before it’s too late.

 

Latest from Op-Ed

State Capture and Electoral Manipulation

Change font size: - + Reset ODIHR Report on Albania’s 2025 Elections Tirana, October 25, 2025. The final report of the OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR) on Albania’s
1 day ago
5 mins read

Obituary

Change font size: - + Reset Remembering Janusz Bugajski: Scholar, Mentor, and Lifelong Friend of the Balkans Janusz Bugajski (1954–2025) The international academic and analytical community has lost one of its most
1 week ago
5 mins read

Albania–Kosovo Rift Weakens the Albanian Voice 

Change font size: - + Reset The Rama–Kurti clash over the war crimes tribunal highlights deeper structural tensions, from unimplemented agreements to competing regional agendas. The latest clash between Albanian Prime Minister
2 weeks ago
3 mins read

Fourth estate’s useful idiots

Change font size: - + Reset (cases from Albania in which international media should had known better) The cashless dream This July, a Politico-Europe journalist texted me about comments regarding Albanian PM
1 month ago
6 mins read